Meta adds a catalog you never asked for

What happened: I duplicated an ad with no catalog, and got a catalog

I built an ad with a single image and no catalog. In Creative setup everything is in order: Products is off, and it says so plainly, Turned off: Site links, Products, Summaries.

So far so good. The trouble starts on duplicate. I took that same ad and hit Duplicate inside the same Ad Set to add another creative, and in the duplicated ad the Products and services block was already on, with a catalog chosen on its own from the account's old catalogs. I did not touch it, approve it or ask for it. Meta chose for me.

Tap to enlarge

Anyone who duplicated an ad just to swap the image or the video, and did not scroll to the bottom, is already running a full catalog.

Back to contents

Why it matters, and why small budgets get hit hardest

If the catalog fits the brief, no harm done. If it does not, you have two problems: you pay for impressions on products you did not want to promote, and you promote something that may no longer be current, an old price or a program that has closed.

This is where budget comes in. On an optimized campaign with a large budget the impact is smaller. The system has enough data to learn quickly that impressions to the catalog do not produce the conversion you are after, and it shifts budget away from them. The waste is a small share of the total, and it corrects itself.

Why a small budget takes the hit

On a small budget it is the opposite. There are not enough conversions to exit the learning phase (Meta wants roughly 50 conversions a week per Ad Set), the system never learns that the catalog is not working, and a real share of your few impressions goes to products you did not want. Instead of reaching the audience the ad was built for, a tight budget is spent on something with no connection to the campaign goal at all.

Back to contents

Not a bug, a pattern

Meta has a long history of turning its newer features on by default: Advantage+‎ enhancements that add music, animation and image tweaks you never asked for, automatic placements, audience expansion that is hard to switch off, budget optimization that ships on. The catalog that lights up on its own during a duplicate is one more variation on the same principle: push the new element in as the default, and let you find it only if you were paying attention. Most of the time nobody is. A fresh example of the same habit: Meta also added auto-scroll and Autofill to lead forms on your landing page, with no off switch there either.

Back to contents

What to do: how to remove a catalog that turned itself on

One rule: after every duplicate, check every element in the ad, not only what you changed. The catalog is one example.

How to remove the catalog, step by step

To check the catalog, open Creative setup. Even when the summary screen says the catalog is off, once you go in you find it is actually on:

Tap to enlarge

To remove it, click the catalog in the edit view and then the "back" arrow:

Then choose Not connected:

When you do want a catalog

And when you do want a catalog, pick it by hand and make sure it is the right, current feed, not the one Meta chose for you.

Thanks to Eli Lavi, owner of the digital agency Thinkadv, for showing me how to remove the catalog.

Back to contents